Skip to main content
PSI Inn | PSI Restaurant | PSI Inn Town Suites | PSI Weddings & Events | Gift Certificates
Peter Shields Inn Logo
  • Home
  • Menus
  • Three Course Tasting
  • Wine Dinner
  • Photos
  • Gift Certificates
  • Contact Us
OpenTable Reservations

Three Course Tasting Menu

Available 5pm - Close
Sunday-Thursday
till November 30th


First Course


Soup of the Day

Baby Romaine Caesar Salad, Garlic Dressing, Tourn Croutons, Parmesan

Deviled Eggs, Chef’s Daily Preparations

Second Course

Catch of the Day, Chef’s Selection Prepared Daily, Seasonal Vegetables

Braised Short Ribs, Mashed Potatoes, Baby Carrots, Red Wine Jus

Pasta Bolognaise, House-Made Rigatoni, Burrata, Pecorino

Third Course

Classic Crème Brûlée, Raspberries, Shortbread Cookie Crisps

Warm Cobbler, Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Flourless Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Crunch Ice Cream, Chocolate Ganache, Chocolate Anglaise


$65 Per Person
(Beverage, Tax and Gratuity Not Included)

$35 Additional 3 Course Wine Pairing


Executive Chef Keith Mitchell

Items and pricing subject to change without notice.
This notice is provided for Website Accessibility best practices
You are leaving petershieldsinn.com
We are redirecting you to...
Website accessibility, security and privacy policies may be different than ours.
Close Notice Continue to Website
facebook iconinstagram icon
Peter Shields Inn - Restaurant
  • 1301 Beach Avenue
  • Cape May, NJ 08204
  • (609) 884-9090
Help Accessibility Statement Privacy Policy Web Design © Restaurant Passion, Inc.